
Clube Ceticismo
Vida extraterrestre? A verdade está lá fora?
Autor: Agnoscetico | Categoria: Ceticismo | Exibições: 69906 Comentários: 55

Fernando Silva[/spoiler]
Trecho do livro "TimeRiders: City of Shadows", de Alex Scarrow, onde um cara vindo de 2070 diz como a humanidade se autodestruiu. Explica que isto acontece a todas as civilizações extraterrestres e que é por isto que elas nunca nos contactaram.
[spoiler]‘Right. And that’s the Fermi Paradox. Why isn’t every frequency full of alien signals?’ He sighed. ‘Because we’re alone. And why are we alone?’ He smiled. He wasn’t expecting them to answer.
‘Well … in my time we figured that out for ourselves. Within a century of discovering radio waves, mankind managed to exhaust the raw materials of the planet. The raw materials, the free energy source that every emerging technological civilization gets as a gift from its historical past – fossil fuels. It’s that package of free energy that we should have used carefully while we took our time to discover and harness quantum energy. Humankind never got a chance to take anything more than a few baby steps into space. We never got the time to mature, to reach out into space, for other worlds. Hydrocarbons. Fossil fuels. Oil. We used it all up far too quickly. Too many people wanting too many things. We used it up,’ he said, sighing, ‘and then, as it began to run out, we turned on each other.’
‘The Oil Wars?’ said Liam. He had heard another traveller from Rashim’s time mention them. A man called Locke.
‘Yes. Wars between India and China. Japan and Korea. The first of those was in the 2040s. Russia and the European Bloc, there was a short war between those. And, of course, what we should have been doing is trying to fix another bigger problem. The world itself dying: warming up, rising tides, poisoned blooms of algae killing the seas.’
Rashim fell silent for a moment. ‘Anyway, that’s the answer to the Fermi Paradox; most – if not all – civilizations either destroy themselves or mine themselves dry long before they ever spread out to other planets and are able to mine, harvest them for resources. Once you’ve exhausted your home planet … it’s all over for you. Either you become extinct, or you eventually end up being cavemen once more.’
‘It’s a one-shot deal?’ said Maddy.
He nodded. ‘And perhaps every civilization makes the same mistake. Spends what it has, thinking it will never run out. Then, all of a sudden, it does.’
‘But on Earth we didn’t just run out. We decided to destroy ourselves in style.’ Rashim snorted. ‘It was some kind of a genetically engineered virus … pretty much wiped us all out in the space of a few weeks. We made a nice tidy job of pretty much erasing ourselves from history.’
If the aliens are out there, why can’t we detect them?
Much is made of the fact that our radio and television broadcasts have been radiating from Earth for almost a century. This is undeniably true. But if this is the case then why aren’t these signals also radiating from other highly developed planets? If they were then we would easily be able to detect them.
The answer of course is that such transmissions exist for only a brief period in a planet’s history. Here on Earth they are unlikely to exist for more than another decade or two. We are rapidly reaching the point where all such broadcasts will be via cable, internet or low-power wireless signals that extend no more than a mile or so from the nearest radio mast. These signals certainly won’t be broadcast into space, and they will almost certainly be undetectable from outside our atmosphere. So as far as radio emissions are concerned, the Earth will appear to “go dark” within the next generation, while life on the planet continues.
If scientific progress runs at the same rate on other planets, and if they’ve developed a few decades ahead of us, they won’t be emitting any radio signals at all by now. Their “radio era” will have ended and it will be impossible for us to detect them by listening out for their radio signals. They might not have had a radio era at all, of course. They might have stuck with cables and low-power wireless, and skipped the high-power broadcasts completely. Or perhaps they used some other form of communications technology: infra red, light (e.g. lasers and fiber optics), microwaves, or something else that we don’t even know about.
Our only real hope of spotting them is if they’re broadcasting radio signals into space deliberately – because they want to be found by highly developed species on other planets. Since we haven’t spotted any so far, it seems that none of the species on nearby planets is currently doing this. If they’re there, they don’t want us to know about it. We know with near certainty that they are out there somewhere, because if they weren’t then we wouldn’t be living here on Earth – in an environment that clearly isn’t our natural one. (*)
fonte: Humans are not from Earth - Ellis Silver. PhD.
(*) Passei o livro para o Pirula, talvez ele se interesse em refutar as idéias num vídeo .
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Data da postagem: 13/12/2021, 13:29
GigaviewNo que diz respeito a ser uma premissa arbitrária tanto quanto achar que se uma coisa é complexa demais só pode ter sido fruto de uma inteligência divina superior, ou coisa parecida.O organoléptico
Esse Paradoxo de Fermi é muito parecido com o Design Inteligente dos Criacionistas.
Em que sentido?
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Data da postagem: 13/12/2021, 15:15

Mudei de ideia e já vejo que não é vantajoso se expor gratuitamente no universo.
Eu achava antes que Stephen Hawking exagerava ao falar de alienígenas perigosos.
O vídeo está muito bem fundamentado.
Eu achava antes que Stephen Hawking exagerava ao falar de alienígenas perigosos.
O vídeo está muito bem fundamentado.
Why We Should NOT Look For Aliens - The Dark Forest
14 de dez. de 2021
Kurzgesagt – In a Nutshell
The Universe is incredibly big and seems full of potential for life, with billions of habitable planets. If an advanced civilization had the technology to travel between the stars, at just 0.1% of the speed of light, It could colonize our galaxy in roughly 100 million years. Which is not that long given the billions of years the milky way has existed – so in principle any spacefaring civilization should be able to spread rapidly over huge sectors of the galaxy. And yet we see nothing, hear nothing, the universe seems empty. Devoid of others. This is the Fermi Paradox, which we have discussed in more detail in other videos.
Confronted with the seemingly empty universe, humanity faces a dilemma. We desperately want to know if we are alone in the Milky Way. We want to call out and reveal ourselves to anyone watching but that could be the last thing we ever do. Because maybe the universe is not empty. Maybe it’s full of civilizations but they are hiding from each other. Maybe the civilizations that attracted attention in the past were wiped away by invisible arrows. This is the Dark Forest solution to the Fermi paradox.
==================
Fixado por Kurzgesagt – In a Nutshell
Kurzgesagt – In a Nutshell
If this video made you curious and you like reading great and long sci fi books, check out the three body problem by Liu Cixin, who formulated the dark forest idea for the first time. And with that, we say good bye to the year 12,021. It truly was a wild time, and passed so, so quickly. For us at the Kurzgesagt team it was full of changes and achievements and we learned so much and tried so many new things. And we have so many exciting ideas and projects that we can’t wait to share with you next year! I know I say this often but doing Kurzgesagt really is just such a joy. We only can do this because of you, so thank you so, so much. We appreciate it more than you might imagine. Have wonderful holidays and get safely into the year 12,022. We’ll see you on the other side! – Philipp
PS: And if you want to help us do what we do, check out our store with sciency products made with love: https://kgs.link/shop
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Data da postagem: 22/12/2021, 22:52

Gabarito[/spoiler]
Mudei de ideia e já vejo que não é vantajoso se expor gratuitamente no universo.
Eu achava antes que Stephen Hawking exagerava ao falar de alienígenas perigosos.
O vídeo está muito bem fundamentado.
[spoiler]
Why We Should NOT Look For Aliens - The Dark Forest
14 de dez. de 2021
Kurzgesagt – In a Nutshell
The Universe is incredibly big and seems full of potential for life, with billions of habitable planets. If an advanced civilization had the technology to travel between the stars, at just 0.1% of the speed of light, It could colonize our galaxy in roughly 100 million years. Which is not that long given the billions of years the milky way has existed – so in principle any spacefaring civilization should be able to spread rapidly over huge sectors of the galaxy. And yet we see nothing, hear nothing, the universe seems empty. Devoid of others. This is the Fermi Paradox, which we have discussed in more detail in other videos.
Confronted with the seemingly empty universe, humanity faces a dilemma. We desperately want to know if we are alone in the Milky Way. We want to call out and reveal ourselves to anyone watching but that could be the last thing we ever do. Because maybe the universe is not empty. Maybe it’s full of civilizations but they are hiding from each other. Maybe the civilizations that attracted attention in the past were wiped away by invisible arrows. This is the Dark Forest solution to the Fermi paradox.
==================
Fixado por Kurzgesagt – In a Nutshell
Kurzgesagt – In a Nutshell
If this video made you curious and you like reading great and long sci fi books, check out the three body problem by Liu Cixin, who formulated the dark forest idea for the first time. And with that, we say good bye to the year 12,021. It truly was a wild time, and passed so, so quickly. For us at the Kurzgesagt team it was full of changes and achievements and we learned so much and tried so many new things. And we have so many exciting ideas and projects that we can’t wait to share with you next year! I know I say this often but doing Kurzgesagt really is just such a joy. We only can do this because of you, so thank you so, so much. We appreciate it more than you might imagine. Have wonderful holidays and get safely into the year 12,022. We’ll see you on the other side! – Philipp
PS: And if you want to help us do what we do, check out our store with sciency products made with love: https://kgs.link/shop
A idéia é interessante desde que aceitemos uma porção de premissas pouco prováveis. Por exemplo, cito 3 delas...
(1) Por que devemos supor que a evolução se processa da mesma forma em todos os lugares? Como seria a evolução numa biologia baseada em silício? Ou, mesmo em carbono mas num planetóide de um sistema estelar binário à beira de um buraco negro? Num contexto universal talvez não seja razoável pensar que seres alienígenas tão diversos estejam lutando pelos mesmos recursos para sobreviver e que talvez não haja necessidade de identificar inimigos ou manifestar comportamentos beligerantes. Pode ser que eles já estejam aqui nos vigiando, por exemplo, "disfarçados" de animais domésticos... :lol:
(2) Por que devemos esperar que os alienígenas se comportem e pensem da mesma forma e com a mesma psicologia dos humanos se eles não são humanos? Quem disse que eles possuem sentimentos, como esse medo dos outros na analogia com o caçador humano?
(3) Por que devemos supor que os alienígenas são organizados numa força armada cósmica com algum tipo de liderança e destruição como nos livros e filmes de sci-fi?
As premissas do Dark Forrest são baseadas em simplificações exageradas:
The fundamental flaw in the Dark Forrest hypothesis is a very naive simplification that Star Trek fans know all too well: the “one culture, one ruler” simplification. Whenever the starship Enterprise visits a planet (first contact or other) there is usually some kind of planetary government or even a single ruler that can make decisions for the whole planet. In defence of Star Trek: to fit in the 50 something minutes long episodes, some simplifications are necessary. And yes, there are some storylines that are a little more complex but these oversimplifications are made very frequently in several of the Star Trek TV series.
The Dark Forrest hypothesis implicitly assumes that an alien civilisation acts as one entity with a coherent behaviour over a very long period of time. That is simply not very likely — and even if it applies to one species (maybe some kind of alien queen that somehow controls all other individuals), it does definitely not apply to all species. Yes, there might be a world government one day that can make all factions or countries comply to a possible CETI ban. But on the way to that future, there will be many more attempts to communicate with alien civilisations.
So where is everybody? If the Dark Forrest hypothesis is not the most likely explanation for the Fermi Paradox, then what is the explanation? I believe that in our galaxy there are probably thousands, maybe millions of worlds with alien lifeforms. However, there are probably very, very few — maybe even none besides Earth — with intelligent alien lifeforms. And even if there are other civilisations out there — maybe their natural and technological evolution took much longer or will take much longer until they will be capable to emit and receive signals. Some alien civilisations might not constantly send signals strong enough into outer space so that we can pick them up after hundreds or thousands of Earth years. Moreover, they might have sent the few signals into the wrong direction (there are in fact a lot of wrong directions from our perspective).
Let’s put our SETI activities into perspective: we have been technologically capable of receiving signals from outer space only for a few decades — the first radio telescope was built only in 1932 (details: here). Compared with the entire 200,000 years of existence of homo sapiens, 89 years are a very short time period. Even 200,000 years is a very short time period compared with the age of Earth, which is roughly 4.5 billion years old… Given the vastness of space and the long time signals need to travel through space to reach us, can we really conclude after using radio telescopes only for 89 years, that alien civilisations don’t exist (or that they are hiding) because we haven’t picked up their signals yet? Maybe we just need to wait a couple of centuries longer and in the meantime make sure that we don’t destroy Earth and, at the same time, ourselves. It would be a pity if humans go extinct a few decades before the first alien signals will pass through our solar system.
https://medium.com/predict/why-the-dark-forest-theory-is-probably-wrong-a3d03568d88d
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Data da postagem: 23/12/2021, 01:53
Cubo metálico na Lua, entre outras anedotas cósmicas.
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Data da postagem: 23/12/2021, 20:53

"Se não existe vida fora da Terra, então o universo é um grande desperdício de espaço." Carl Sagan.
Acredito fortemente que haja vida em outros lugares do Universo.
Acredito fortemente que haja vida em outros lugares do Universo.
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Data da postagem: 20/02/2023, 13:23

Batman
"Se não existe vida fora da Terra, então o universo é um grande desperdício de espaço." Carl Sagan.
Acredito fortemente que haja vida em outros lugares do Universo.
O fato de Carl Sagan achar que universo é um grande desperdício de espaço não prova que seja, pois o desperdício um conceito humano. O universo não é como uma entidade consciente que planeja como o próprio espaço deve ser gerenciado.
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Data da postagem: 25/02/2023, 15:13

Li um microconto na Internet:
Após guerras ferozes envolvendo as civilizações da galáxia, uma espécie muito violenta foi reduzida a apenas dois indivíduos.
Em vez de executados, foram abandonados, sem nenhum recurso, num planeta selvagem. Esperava-se que não durassem muito.
Milhares de anos depois, uma nave passou por esse planeta, resolveu dar uma olhada e ficaram chocados:
Os dois exilados tinham, não apenas sobrevivido, mas já havia 7 bilhões deles povoando todo o planeta.
O capitão ouviu um barulho na janela, foi olhar e era um daqueles descendentes, num traje espacial, tentando chamar sua atenção.
Assustados, eles foram embora correndo.
O astronauta voltou à base e se lamentou: "Mais uma nave de ETs que se recusa a falar conosco ..."
Ah, sim: os dois exilados se chamavam Adão e Eva.
Após guerras ferozes envolvendo as civilizações da galáxia, uma espécie muito violenta foi reduzida a apenas dois indivíduos.
Em vez de executados, foram abandonados, sem nenhum recurso, num planeta selvagem. Esperava-se que não durassem muito.
Milhares de anos depois, uma nave passou por esse planeta, resolveu dar uma olhada e ficaram chocados:
Os dois exilados tinham, não apenas sobrevivido, mas já havia 7 bilhões deles povoando todo o planeta.
O capitão ouviu um barulho na janela, foi olhar e era um daqueles descendentes, num traje espacial, tentando chamar sua atenção.
Assustados, eles foram embora correndo.
O astronauta voltou à base e se lamentou: "Mais uma nave de ETs que se recusa a falar conosco ..."
Ah, sim: os dois exilados se chamavam Adão e Eva.
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Data da postagem: 25/02/2023, 17:24

AgnosceticoBatman
"Se não existe vida fora da Terra, então o universo é um grande desperdício de espaço." Carl Sagan.
Acredito fortemente que haja vida em outros lugares do Universo.
O fato de Carl Sagan achar que universo é um grande desperdício de espaço não prova que seja, pois o desperdício um conceito humano. O universo não é como uma entidade consciente que planeja como o próprio espaço deve ser gerenciado.
Citei a frase de Carl Sagan apenas para ilustrar e reforçar que dada a imensidão do universo é quase que impossível na minha opinião que só haja vida no planeta Terra.
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Data da postagem: 26/02/2023, 08:22

Batman
Citei a frase de Carl Sagan apenas para ilustrar e reforçar que dada a imensidão do universo é quase que impossível na minha opinião que só haja vida no planeta Terra.
Seria quase impossível o contrário. Já que pra surgir uma vida de forma espontânea é muito mais difícil, já que a vida é um sistema complexo formada de muitas moléculas organizadas que precisam ter atividade coordenada pra manter o organismo funcionando. Se fosse surgir vida devido a extensão do universo, teria formas de vida surgindo com mais frequência do que houve a bilhões de anos atrás.
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Data da postagem: 26/02/2023, 21:17